Skip to content
Good food. Growing things. Everyday home life.Meet Nancy On The Home Front

Food & kitchen · Kitchen guide

How to bake potatoes

Choose potatoes suitable for baking, scrub and dry them, then bake until the centre is tender and finish with the toppings you enjoy.

Read this guide online: https://nancyonthehomefront.com/how-to-bake-potatoes/

A fork reaches the soft centre of an opened baked potato on a plate.

A baked potato makes a useful starting point for dinner: a soft middle, a skin you can eat and room for a topping. Give it enough oven time and check the centre before serving, especially when the potatoes in the bag are different sizes.

Choose potatoes that suit baking

Look for potatoes labelled for baking and choose a similar size for the same batch. Russets have the drier flesh and thicker skin described in Iowa State University's baked-potato guide. A potato that is much larger than its neighbours will usually need more time.

Plan the topping while you choose the potatoes. A large potato with a generous filling can be the main part of a meal; smaller ones work well beside another dish. Decide what you need before filling every spare space on the oven rack.

Scrub, dry and prick the skins

Wash your hands and scrub the potatoes under running water, using a clean brush where needed. Dry the skins with a clean towel. The FDA's produce guidance advises washing produce before cutting it and keeping soap or detergent off the food itself.

Prick each potato with a fork, following the baking method you are using. Put an oven mitt and tongs within reach before you start cooking, so you can handle the hot potatoes without searching through a drawer.

Bake in a preheated oven

Iowa State's method uses a preheated oven at 425°F, about 220°C, with medium potatoes placed directly on the oven rack for about an hour. That is a useful starting point for that size and method. Keep the recipe's oven setting if it gives separate conventional and fan instructions.

Leave room between the potatoes so you can reach each one with the tongs. Bake them without wrapping them in foil for this rack method. If you are cooking other food alongside them, check that its timing and oven temperature fit the same plan.

Use the temperature converter when you need the Celsius or Fahrenheit number from a recipe. It changes the number; the recipe still supplies the oven mode and cooking instructions.

Check the middle before serving

Use the oven mitts or tongs to steady a potato and test its centre with a fork. The fork should enter the middle easily. A firm centre needs more oven time, even if the outside already looks ready.

Check the largest potato in the batch as well as a smaller one. Remove the potatoes that are ready and let the others finish, rather than cutting into all of them at once. Keep your hands clear of the steam as you open a cooked potato.

Open it and add the topping

Cut a slit along the top, open the potato and loosen the middle with a fork. Add the topping while the potato is hot. Butter and grated cheese are simple choices; beans or leftover cooked vegetables can make a fuller meal.

For a vegetable topping, our broccoli guide helps you cook pieces that fit neatly into the opened potato. If you want a different potato side, try boiled potatoes or the roasting guide.

Put spare potatoes away promptly

Follow USDA leftover guidance: refrigerate within two hours, or one hour above 90°F/32°C. Use shallow containers, keep the refrigerator at 40°F/4°C or below and use refrigerated leftovers within three to four days. Reheat to 165°F/74°C, checked with a food thermometer.

Label the container with the cooking date so the spare potatoes are easy to use. For longer storage, our potato-freezing guide explains how the cooked dish affects the result.

A LITTLE MORE FROM NANCY

Nancy

Find something good to cook, get a small garden started or pick up a useful idea for your home.

Meet Nancy