I grew up with the tradition of going out with the family and cutting down a live Christmas tree. We would head out to a local tree farm, find the perfect tree and cut it down. After we were married we continued this tradition with our children. We did this every year until we moved to Florida and there were no local tree farms around.


The first year we lived in Florida our friends shipped us a live tree from LLBean! Yes you can actually ship a live tree through the mail! Not the small tabletop trees they now sell but a full size Christmas tree!Christmas tree


When we moved into our first home in Florida we decided that perhaps purchasing an artificial tree would make more sense. At the time (early ’90s) we spent what we thought was a lot of money on an artificial tree – $189! It was a beautiful tree that you would assemble branch by branch. Turns out it was an amazing investment as we used the tree for the next 21 years averaging out to a cost of $9.00 a year! We even moved the tree to Vermont and used it every year!Christmas tree


With an eventual move coming up and trying to get rid of the things that we will not move we decided to sell our artificial tree. It was still in excellent condition and although it had lost some needles over the years when it was decorated you really couldn’t tell it was fake.Christmas tree So we sold the tree this fall. Hoping that perhaps we’d have an offer on our home before Christmas.


Well that didn’t happen and here we are celebrating yet another Christmas in Vermont. No children or grandchildren home this year but we decided to go out and purchase a live tree from a local tree farm.Christmas tree


Our tree is adorable but half the height of our old artificial tree. Not to mention this tree must be watered every day as we have a woodstove and the tree tends to drink water! I imagine the tree will have to come down shortly after Christmas because the needles will start falling out.Christmas tree


Bottom line, when we eventually relocate to the Pacific Northwest we will once again invest in an artificial tree. Although I love the smell of a fresh tree the pros of an artificial tree out weigh the enjoyment of a fresh tree.Christmas tree


With an artificial tree you can set it up the weekend after Thanksgiving and it will still look as good for New Years. You don’t have to worry about daily watering. The branches are sturdy and can actually be moved so you can hang an ornament just right! The only downside besides the lack of smell is the fact that you have to store it each year.


What sort of tree do you have? I was always a live tree type of person but over the years I have changed my mind!frugal tips, prudent living




8 comments on “Christmas Tree: Live or Artificial?

ColleenB.~Texas on December 14, 2016 2:54 pm

As a child growing up we always had a real tree that my dad would go out and cut down himself but after getting married and having children our youngest daughter could not be around a live tree so had to switch to artificial.
Over the years I have switched from our 8 foot tall artificial tree down to a small wall tree being it’s just me and my husband now and the wall tree is perfect for us

Nancy Wolff on December 14, 2016 7:40 pm

That sounds like a perfect Christmas tree!

Deborah on December 14, 2016 9:43 pm

Artificial, I have allergies. And I like to put it up the first of November and leave it up until Epiphany!

Nancy Wolff on December 15, 2016 2:34 pm

I love being able to put up a tree (artificial) Thanksgiving weekend through New Years!

Kelly on December 15, 2016 12:01 am

Gorgeous tree! I have always wanted to do a little train below my tree, but our pets are always messing with the tree so I couldn’t. Sure love the look.

Nancy Wolff on December 15, 2016 2:34 pm

I love our little train!

Marilyn on December 15, 2016 4:04 am

We have always had a live tree. It is always about 8 feet.

Nancy Wolff on December 15, 2016 2:33 pm

That sounds like an amazing tree!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Never Miss a Post!

Find Me


Nancy’s Archives